Pathways to Citizenship
Key Point Summary
- Majorities of Americans favor providing undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. a route to legal status. Favorability for some type of such pathway exceeds opposition in nearly every question format tested. Baseline questions asked of national adults produce agreement between 53% and 68%, with opposition between 25% and 34% [1, 2, 3, 4]. Questions posing a pathway as an option instead of deportation produce a comparable range of favorability between 55% and 70%, among both national adults and adults registered to vote [5, 6].
- Questions specifying circumstances can increase Americans’ favorable opinions about undocumented immigrants living in this country. A pathway for immigrants who have been in the country for many years and who pass a background check draws 74% and 79% acceptance among adults registered to vote in two surveys [7, 8]. Work permits for immigrants here at least five years, who hold jobs and have no criminal record, draw 72% favorability among national adults [9]. Questions mentioning economic and family ties also increase favorability when presented as considerations.
- Among those who favor legalization, citizenship is preferred over permanent residency. When asked as a follow-up, however, about four in ten of those who would allow undocumented immigrants to stay choose permanent residency rather than citizenship [10].
- Polls of national adults and adults registered to vote point in the same direction, and the available evidence does not indicate that the choice between these populations changes the conclusion.
Baseline Opinion
Americans’ favorability toward some form of a way to move toward legal status for undocumented immigrants living in the country exceeds opposition in nearly every question format tested.
Baseline questions asking national adults to favor or oppose a pathway to citizenship produce favorability between 53% and 68%, with opposition between 25% and 34% [1, 2, 3, 4]. Questions posing a pathway as an option instead of deportation produce a comparable positive range, 55% to 70%, among both national adults and adults registered to vote [5, 6].
Policy and Implementation Specifics
Survey researchers have asked about legal status in several ways:
- Simple favor/oppose questions on a pathway to citizenship, with no further detail
- Legalization posed as a direct choice against deportation
- “A way to stay in the country legally,” with no mention of citizenship
- Immigrants described in general terms, or with conditions such as holding a job, paying taxes, years of residence, or absence of a criminal record
- A middle option such as permanent residency or guest worker status
- Forced binary choice, or an explicit “neither favor nor oppose” response
Americans’ opinions vary across these wordings. The largest and most consistent positive effect on opinion comes from describing the immigrants’ employment, tax payment, and length of residence.
- A question about a pathway to citizenship for immigrants who have been in the U.S. for many years and pass a background check draws 74% favorability among adults registered to vote and 79% in a second survey by the same organization [7, 8].
- A question about work permits for immigrants here at least five years who have jobs and no criminal record draws 72% of national adults in favor and 27% opposed [9].
Offering an explicit “neither favor nor oppose” option (roughly a fifth choose this position) pulls respondents out of both camps, and so does not appear to affect the underlying direction of opinion.
Asked about characteristics that could increase or decrease an immigrant’s chances of being allowed to stay in the country, national adults were most likely to say that holding a job and paying taxes should increase the chances (63%), followed by ten or more years of residence (52%), being the parent of a child with legal status (52%), and running a small business (51%) [11].
Specifying characteristics unrelated to economic or family contribution produced lower percentages saying that the characteristic should increase an immigrant’s chances of staying in the country: regular religious attendance (12% say this should increase an immigrant’s chances), low levels of education (8%), and limited English (8%) [11].
Receiving government assistance for food or housing moved responses in the other direction, with 39% saying this should decrease an immigrant’s chances to remain in the country [11].
One survey question asks whether certain characteristics should be required in order to stay in the country legally, considered but not required, or neither. A majority of national adults say that passing a security background check (79%) and holding a job (52%) should be a requirement [10]. All others tested find much lower percentages of adults saying that they should be a requirement for staying in the country legally.
The language used to describe the specifics involved in the process of allowing undocumented immigrants to stay in the country produces differences in opinion:
- One survey of national adults uses two wordings. One asks about a “pathway to citizenship” for all undocumented immigrants currently living in the U.S. and finds 65% support [3]. The other asks about granting “legal status to all undocumented immigrants who have held jobs and paid taxes in the United States for at least 3 years and have not been convicted of any felony crimes” and finds the percentage of those in favor essentially the same, at 64% [3].
- The use of the words “illegal,” “undocumented,” and “unauthorized” has little apparent independent effect. A recurring question about “illegal immigrants who have jobs” produces favorability between 58% and 66% among adults registered to vote, in line with more neutrally worded questions carrying the same employment condition [12, 13, 14].
Favorability toward allowing immigrants to stay legally is not the same as favorability toward citizenship.
- One organization first asks whether undocumented immigrants should be allowed to stay legally if certain requirements are met, with 64% of national adults saying yes [10]. Those respondents are then asked whether those immigrants should be eligible for citizenship or for permanent residency only: 60% choose citizenship and 39% permanent residency [10].
- One survey finds 64% favoring eventual citizenship, but that figure comes from a follow-up question asked only of respondents who first said undocumented immigrants should be allowed to stay in the country legally. As a share of all national adults, it corresponds to roughly 36% to 38% across separate surveys [15].
- These differences in support are driven by question wording. When citizenship, permanent residency, and deportation are offered as alternatives for the ultimate status of undocumented immigrants who move toward a legal status, permanent residency draws only 13% to 17% and citizenship rises to between 57% and 67% [16, 17, 18]. When offered only after respondents have already agreed to legalization, permanent residency draws 39% [10].
Putting It All Together
Americans favor providing a legal pathway for undocumented immigrants, particularly for those described as employed, long-resident, and without criminal records. When asked about the ultimate status for these immigrants, citizenship draws more favorability than permanent residency in every format tested. The share choosing permanent residency depends on how the question is asked. It is 13% to 17% when citizenship, permanent residency, and deportation are offered together, and 39% when the question is asked only of those who first said undocumented immigrants should be allowed to stay [10, 16, 17, 18].
Sources
This section cites 18 surveys: 12 of national adults (23 questions, approximately 41,000 respondents) and 6 of adults registered to vote (6 questions, approximately 7,400 respondents).
[1] Politico/Ipsos. (2023). Politico/Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded May 12-14, 2023. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[2] Reuters/Ipsos. (2025). Reuters/Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded Feb. 13-18, 2025. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[3] Ipsos. (2023). Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded March 21-29, 2023. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[4] Reuters/Ipsos. (2025). Reuters/Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded April 16-21, 2025. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[5] Quinnipiac University. (2024). Quinnipiac University Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Dec. 12-16, 2024. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[6] CNN/SSRS. (2025). CNN Poll. National adults. Fielded April 17-24, 2025. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[7] The Wall Street Journal. (2024). Wall Street Journal Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Feb. 21-28, 2024.
[8] The Wall Street Journal. (2025). Wall Street Journal Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Jan. 9-14, 2025.
[9] Marquette Law School/SSRS. (2025). Marquette Law School National Survey. National adults. Fielded Nov. 5-12, 2025. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[10] Pew Research Center/SSRS. (2024). American Trends Panel. National adults. Fielded Aug. 5-11, 2024. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[11] Ipsos. (2026). Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded Feb. 25-March 4, 2026. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[12] Fox News/Beacon Research/Shaw & Co. Research. (2024). Fox News Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Aug. 9-12, 2024.
[13] Fox News/Beacon Research/Shaw & Co. Research. (2024). Fox News Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Oct. 11-14, 2024.
[14] Fox News/Beacon Research/Shaw & Co. Research. (2023). Fox News Poll. National adults registered to vote. Fielded Feb. 19-22, 2023. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[15] Pew Research Center/SSRS. (2025). American Trends Panel. National adults. Fielded June 2-8, 2025. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[16] PRRI/Ipsos. (2022). PRRI/Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded Sept. 1-11, 2022. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[17] PRRI/Ipsos. (2023). PRRI/Ipsos Poll. National adults. Fielded Aug. 25-30, 2023. Accessed via Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
[18] NORC at the University of Chicago. (2022). General Social Survey 2022. National adults. Fielded May 4-Dec. 20, 2022.